About that 47-Story Tower Down by Extell on the Waterfront

Posted on: March 9th, 2016 at 5:18 am by

This image has been archived or removed.

The now-closed Pathmark Pharmacy, October 2012

​Drama down on the Lower East Side waterfront. While Extell’s 80-story market-rate phallus (aka One Manhattan Square) ascends to sights unseen, the neighboring Pathmark Pharmacy site remains in contention for another potential tower. Despite the ongoing litigation.

Roy Schoenberg (pka Little Cherry LLC) previously partnered with Two Bridges Neighborhood Council and Settlement Housing Fund to construct a 47- story residential (mixed income) tower at 237-247 Cherry Street. But TBNC, which owns the land beneath the brick box, backed out of the deal. The sudden action was suspicious, and potentially due to what could be an alleged courtship with Extell, one that ultimately triggered a $50 million lawsuit from Schoenberg.

You see, Extell bought out the remainder of the lease to the Pathamark Pharmacy half of the building (until 2044), and probably wants to acquire the land itself. Indeed, Gary Barnett even mentioned plans to develop the property during his first meet-and-greet with the community two years ago. As leaseholder for the other half, Schoenberg’s initital proposal stands in the way of that goal. So, it’s not such a long-shot to imagine the potential backroom dealing.

This image has been archived or removed.

Word on the street is that Two Bridges Neighborhood Council recently sent a letter to Community Board 3 regarding the Chinatown Working Group zoning proposal and its treatment of the waterfront (Subsection D). The nonprofit specifically asked for no height caps in the area. Mind boggling, as it could eventually lead to a wall of glass along the South Street waterfront. We’re also told that the residents of Two Bridges Tower (82 Rutgers), at one point, proposed a bi-level, affordable supermarket for this vacant building, but were rejected by TBNC.

Meanwhile, the aforementioned lawsuit is still pending, so the development is very much on the back burner, but could still happen in the near future. After all, plenty of big money is at stake here…

This image has been archived or removed.

Below are some vital stats about the Little Cherry project at 237-247 Cherry, should it happen:

  • The Cherry Street tower would cantilever over half of the existing pharmacy building (due to Extell’s lease), effectively blocking sunlight for the senior building at 80 Rutgers.
  • This project, combined with Extell’s 80-story behemoth, would immediately add approximately 3,000 new condominium owners to a single block, in an area deemed a flood zone.
  • TBNC is using every method possible to prevent this from the UULRP/public review process. Two members of its staff were appointed last year to Community Board 3. One is on land use.
  • Locals must already suffer the Extell nightmare, so adding another super-tall construction would worsen quality of life immeasurably.

Recent Stories

Developer Begins Demolition of Rutgers Street Playground for Temporary Parking Lot

Demolition work began this week on a Lower East Side park that is a focal point in the tension between the community and developers on the waterfront. The backhoes are out and job now underway at Rutgers Park, the small public space beside the Lands End II residential development. Removal of the playground began yesterday, including […]

The 3 Lower East Side Walk-ups that Sold for $35M

Earlier this month, we reported that SMA Equities, the Long Island real estate firm with controversial history on the Lower East Side, sold a portfolio of its area properties. SMA unloaded three tenement walk-ups to Daniel Fishman of GAIA Real Estate – 102 Norfolk Street, 177 Ludlow Street, and 99 Allen Street – for an […]

H&M Debuts Pop-up Hotel on the Bowery this Weekend

Fashion retailer, H&M, is headed to the Lower East Side this week with a pop-up hotel concept. Starting tomorrow, prospective guests can access the so-called Hotel Hennes via the eponymous 3 Freeman Alley. The three-day publicity stunt will be open through Saturday, from 2 to 9pm. Guests will be able to check in for an […]

Sneakerhead Arrested for Knifing Customer at Hypebeast ‘HBX’ Opening on Division Street

A watershed moment for Hypebeast transformed into a melee on the Lower East Side last week. The Hong Kong-based fashion and lifestyle publication on Friday officially debuted in the seven-story commercial loft building at 41-43 Division Street. Its ground-level store – dubbed HBX – attracted a queue of sneaker heads waiting for a limited edition Nike […]

Arsonist Torches Eldridge Street Beauty Parlor

Two people were injured yesterday evening after an arsonist set ablaze a beauty parlor on Eldridge Street, according to several published reports. The incident transpired shortly before 5:00pm at the Sa Sa II Beauty Salon, located at 129 Eldridge Street. Cops said the suspect poured gasoline inside the store and set it on fire. (Initial […]