Peanut Butter & Company Closes its Greenwich Village Shop After 17 Years

Posted on: March 2nd, 2016 at 5:10 am by
This image has been archived or removed.

Over the weekend, we found ourselves jonesin’ for a fluffer-nutter (i.e. Fluff + peanut butter), so we headed westbound to Greenwich Village. Emotions quickly changed from hungry excitement to disappointment. Tombstone leasing signage now sits in the windows of 240 Sullivan Street – home of the famous Peanut Butter & Company.

The popular sandwich spot closed its doors forever last week. The brand and business lives on, however, through its wholesale operation. You’ve probably seen its peanut butter product in your local supermarket.

Lee Zalben founded Peanut Butter & Company at 240 Sullivan Street seventeen years ago. It’s never changed locations. This business is often considered the progenitor of the “single ingredient” restaurant so pervasive in the city these days (e.g. Meatball Shop, Rice to Riches, S’Mac).

“I love this little shop,” Lee Zalben noted in a statement. “This is the place where Peanut Butter & Co. was born, so of course I’m a little sad to see it close. But the truth is, it’s just sooo small. In the last several years we’ve grown in so many ways – and when customers visit, they’re expecting a grand flagship for the brand, not a homey little shop.”

However, a new location or dedicated food truck is reportedly in the works.

“In the future, we hope to find another location with enough space to expand the menu,” Zalben says. “Until then, we’re excited at the opportunity to try out some pop-ups and maybe even go mobile with a PB&J food truck!”

Circumstances of the closure are not fully known. The aforementioned press statement is obviously spun in a cheery manner without explanation. Reading between the lines, one could jump to a conclusion that perhaps the company was forced from the premises.

In the meantime, wholesale dominates, albeit with little New York City presence. You see, production of the spread moved its facilities to Georgia in 2006 to be closer to their peanut farms. Before that, much of the hard work was conducted in Greenpoint.

Recent Stories

DOT Reinstalls Chinatown Bilingual Street Signs

The Department of Transportation yesterday began replacing bilingual street signs around Chinatown that had been removed for reasons such as damage or construction projects. Crews showed up early on Mott Street to install a missing sign at the corner of Mosco, then proceeded to other spots in the neighborhood. The bilingual street signs first appeared […]

After 120 Years, Future of Parisi Bakery Looks Uncertain on Mott Street

Parisi Bakery, an institution in Little Italy dating back to the turn of the last century, appears to be on shaky ground. The landlord (May Leun Realty) last week taped an official Notice of Termination to the shuttered roll-down gate at 198 Mott Street. Seemingly signaling the end an era. The letter noted a cancelation […]

The Push to Save New York Eye and Ear Infirmary Building, as LPC Stalls

With plans to close the 165-year-old New York Eye and Ear Infirmary building on Second Avenue, demolition is likely the next step. Preservation-minded groups have been lobbying the city to save the building from possible destruction. Led by Village Preservation, the organization sent a Request for Evaluation letter to the Landmarks Preservation Commission on April […]

Excavation Underway on Affordable Grand Street Guild Towers

Work is officially underway on two new towers adjacent to the Williamsburg Bridge. On-site excavation has been ongoing for several weeks at Broome and Clinton Streets, yielding plenty of dust and noise for neighbors. Earlier this year, demolition crews razed the two-story parking garage and Little Star early childhood center in the shadow of the […]

Mr. Fong’s Owner Plans All Day Cafe on Hester Street

Another day, another principal of Mr. Fong’s starting a new Lower East Side venture. Aisa Shelley – who co-founded the Chinatown hotspot with Lucas Moran, Noah Shelley, Daniel Eric Gold and Adam Moonves – is headed to 61 Hester Street. The long-inactive storefront previously occupied by L’estudio. There, Shelley will impart an “all day cafe” […]