‘POPS’ Goes the Elizabeth Street Garden

Posted on: September 5th, 2018 at 5:00 am by

January 2015

One of the most hotly contested subjects at the June CB2 meeting was over actual size of the public space versus green space. Flyers for Haven Green boast 8,600 square-feet of “publicly accessible open space,” that can be influenced by public discourse. Architects broke down the actual amount of “garden space” in response to Bowery Boogie’s request as 6,600 square-feet. The remaining square-footage can be influenced, but is dual-use space that acts as both public and enclosed amenity space for the residents and commercial tenants. (ESG is 20,000 square-feet.)

Garden Advocates also bristled at the faux realism of landscape renderings. Specifically, the pathway illustrated connecting Mott to Elizabeth Street, which apparently does not show ADA compliance. A realistic depiction of the garden would include a wheelchair accessible pathway. But then the inclusion of a five-foot-wide hard surface pathway would diminish the green aspect of the architect’s landscape rendering. (DCP zoning rules for a block-through public plaza call for a 10-foot-wide path.)

Whether realistic or idealistic, omitting wheelchair-accessible pathways from an affordable housing project designed for seniors calls into question Haven Green’s ability to lead a public design meeting with reliable and unbiased information.

Haven Green did not respond to the accusation of “fictional renderings” at the CB2 meeting, but has since stated that “the renderings were a placeholder concept of how the garden space could be designed… the final design will be in response to the public design process.” Meanwhile, Haven Green continues using the contested images in its marketing materials.

When asked if the five street trees outside Elizabeth Street Garden will survive the development, Haven Green again deferred to the participatory design process. In fact, most of the questions we posed resulted in deference to the participatory design process.

With almost every query referred to the public’s opinion, Haven Green’s participatory design process can be interpreted as either a hyper-democratic solution to the problem of public space design or a complete reversal of responsibility.

If this seven-story complex ultimately rises on the east side of the city-owned lot as planned, Garden advocates believe that the shadows cast by the structure will eliminate any chance to “preserve the legacy of the garden through direct public engagement” To their credit, though, Haven Green has published a complete year-round shadow survey on its site, which shows that the southwest corner of the lot is lost in shadow throughout most of the day on a year-round basis – this part of ESG is mainly used for composting and storage.

In the above schematic Haven Green claims the benefit of southern exposure but omits the trees in the Little Italy Restoration Apartments (21 Spring Street) courtyard which are almost as tall as the building.

Conversely, when the renderings show the garden, the trees in the LIRA courtyard suddenly returns, giving the space a greener look.

When asked by a longtime resident of 21 Spring Street whether or not Haven Green could provide enough seating, and green space, for residents in the adjacent building, Karen Haycox responded with hope that the 400+ neighbors of Haven Green could have a seat but could not guarantee one. With less than 30% of the ESG space surviving, the consortium of developers is seeking public input on the privatization of city-owned land that may not be large enough to accommodate its own residents, Habitat NY personnel, and retail customers in the public space.

This story has multiple pages:

Recent Stories

What You Missed at the ‘Uncapped’ SIGNS Group Show [Recap]

Have you ever walked by a fallen street sign plowed down by a car or ons swapped with fancier new models and thought, I really like that, and I’m taking it home. Luckily for a group of likedminded people, there is a collection of weathered or shiny, sparkling or grimy, flat surfaces to litter with the […]

Trees in East River Park Get the Axe Ahead of Resiliency Project

Timber! Monday was the first day of a new reality inside East River Park. From here on out, it won’t be the same; razed and rebuilt based on a controversial $1.45 billion resiliency plan. With much of the park sealed during the phased construction period – the whole capital project carries an estimated five-year completion […]

‘26Red’ Revives ‘90s Streetwear with Orchard Street Boutique

The nineties called, it wants its apparel brand back. Indeed, the recent resurgence of 26Red this year – revived from obscurity by owner John Bernard – has resulted in a new Lower East Side boutique. There is now a dedicated, 600 square-foot store at 145 Orchard Street in Hell Square. (Inside the former DaRucci leather […]

101 Delancey Street Sells for $10.4M

An anchor tenement on situated on Delancey Street within the orbit of Essex Crossing just changed hands. The pre-war “Karg Building” at 101 Delancey – with Popeyes and HSBC bank on the ground floor – is now under the ownership of investor Zack Hering of 33 Equities. His company spent $10.4 million on the transaction. […]

Armed Man in Wheelchair Fires Shots into Crowd on Madison Street

An armed man in a wheelchair allegedly fired shots into a crowd of people outside a Lower East Side bodega Friday night, police said. Leroy Mensah, 28, brandished a (stolen) 9mm gun outside the Stop 1 Deli on Madison Street and Rutgers Street shortly before 10:00pm on Friday. Officers on patrol reportedly chased down the […]